So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
I'm not sure what is meant by for real. Cheating in order to get an advantage (illegal substances consumed or applied to the ball) 3 is not the same as throwing a match or bowling deliberate no balls.
I think the punishments are not overly lenient. However I have little respect for Aussie politicians trying to make out that this is something unlike Aussie sport - plenty of examples of dubious tactics in the past. Du Plessis has form in this area. Perhaps the Aussie cameras don't focus on the trousers of the fielders as much as the SA counterparts.
Not overly lenient? Are you for real? Just for context purposes, Arthur Masuaku got a 6 match ban for West Ham (of whom I am no way a supporter) for spitting. Wouldn't have been surprised if it had been a life ban for Smith. And Bancroft should not hide behind the "youthful naievity" flag. 5 year ban for him would have been just.
I think, Stewyww that this is an issue of semantics - it took the original comment 'for real' as in the sense of fixing results, not just cheating. Doping in sports like cycling is endemic, reflecting the limits of these as 'true sports' rather than pharma-chemical based activities that require a particular (enhanced) physiology rather than skill. Match fixing is the equivalent for cricket because you can't dope an ordinary bowler/batsman into a great one IMHO, but arranging results/plays is going to destroy the credibility of the game.
I have no problem with the idea of Smith and Warner losing their 'leadership' roles and picking up bans. Whether life bans are sustainable, I'm not a sports lawyer. However, even a year's ban (like Warne) would make a serious statement: providing it covered all forms of cricket, of course. Another point I made was that the opposition captain had been caught doing similar things, twice but picks up some demerit points.
The Saffer media doesn't seem to have reacted as violently as the Aussie media/politicians to their miscreant. The Aussie media storm I feel is a bit rich given what they're team has got away with in the past.
At least it's hidden the more important issue - England being hammered in a Test for only the 10th time. Ever.