Essex Outfielder : The Unofficial Essex CCC Forum
Off-Topic => In The Hut => Topic started by: jwb on March 24, 2018, 05:03:55 PM
-
I see the Aussies are playing to the spirit of the game again. They seem quite brazen about it as well but when you’re caught bang to rights there’s nowhere to hide I suppose. Long bans I hope will be forthcoming for those involved.
-
Very amusing to see it unfold live on TV. They did it so badly.
-
Smith and Lehmann should both resign, failing which the Aussie Board should sack them. What made it worse was the cowardly way they got the most junior player in the team, and the least sure of his place, to do the dirty work.
-
Any comments by ex England Team Captain on the subject ?
If not they could get French striker over from the soccer channel.
-
It will be interesting to know who is in the "leadership group" that made this decision.
If this was a "group" decision, then they all have collective responsibility. Going to be an interesting couple of days!!
-
Whilst they are not the first to succumb to temptation, given the furore over recent months under the increasingly stringent rules, why do this now?
Certainly the most dramatic event in cricket since the Pakistani team forfeited that Test.
-
BAN SMITH & WARNER FOR A YEAR AT LEAST. DROP BANCROFT SHOULD BE REHABILITATED IN TIME. SACK LEHMAN & SAKER .
-
Not often that cricket is the first thing on the BBC News - it's often not the first thing on the BBC Sports News, even when our national team is playing.
Lynda and Steve
-
So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
-
So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
I'm not sure what is meant by for real. Cheating in order to get an advantage (illegal substances consumed or applied to the ball) 3 is not the same as throwing a match or bowling deliberate no balls.
I think the punishments are not overly lenient. However I have little respect for Aussie politicians trying to make out that this is something unlike Aussie sport - plenty of examples of dubious tactics in the past. Du Plessis has form in this area. Perhaps the Aussie cameras don't focus on the trousers of the fielders as much as the SA counterparts.
-
So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
I'm not sure what is meant by for real. Cheating in order to get an advantage (illegal substances consumed or applied to the ball) 3 is not the same as throwing a match or bowling deliberate no balls.
I think the punishments are not overly lenient. However I have little respect for Aussie politicians trying to make out that this is something unlike Aussie sport - plenty of examples of dubious tactics in the past. Du Plessis has form in this area. Perhaps the Aussie cameras don't focus on the trousers of the fielders as much as the SA counterparts.
For real means genuine. You seem to be suggesting that it’s ok as they are all at it. Maybe so but is that what we should accept?
-
Like the way Lehman has faced the media and taken the heat like a man!!!! I do not for one minute believe that he had no idea, I dont think there could have been many in that dressing room that were not aware. His face when he was caught with the walkie talkie was classic.
I like the video of Bancroft filling his pocket with sugar during the ashes also!!!
-
So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
I'm not sure what is meant by for real. Cheating in order to get an advantage (illegal substances consumed or applied to the ball) 3 is not the same as throwing a match or bowling deliberate no balls.
I think the punishments are not overly lenient. However I have little respect for Aussie politicians trying to make out that this is something unlike Aussie sport - plenty of examples of dubious tactics in the past. Du Plessis has form in this area. Perhaps the Aussie cameras don't focus on the trousers of the fielders as much as the SA counterparts.
Not overly lenient? Are you for real? Just for context purposes, Arthur Masuaku got a 6 match ban for West Ham (of whom I am no way a supporter) for spitting. Wouldn't have been surprised if it had been a life ban for Smith. And Bancroft should not hide behind the "youthful naievity" flag. 5 year ban for him would have been just.
-
...
I like the video of Bancroft filling his pocket with sugar during the ashes also!!!
Why is there never a swarm of wasps when you need one?
-
Why is there never a swarm of wasps when you need one?
There was a swarm of locusts that made KP hit the deck in the IPL so there must be a God even if it's a Hindu one.
-
So that’s how you stop it. 1 match ban and forfeit whole current test fee. Pathetic but thems the rules. It’s getting like cycling when you cant be sure sure if it’s for real or not.
I'm not sure what is meant by for real. Cheating in order to get an advantage (illegal substances consumed or applied to the ball) 3 is not the same as throwing a match or bowling deliberate no balls.
I think the punishments are not overly lenient. However I have little respect for Aussie politicians trying to make out that this is something unlike Aussie sport - plenty of examples of dubious tactics in the past. Du Plessis has form in this area. Perhaps the Aussie cameras don't focus on the trousers of the fielders as much as the SA counterparts.
Not overly lenient? Are you for real? Just for context purposes, Arthur Masuaku got a 6 match ban for West Ham (of whom I am no way a supporter) for spitting. Wouldn't have been surprised if it had been a life ban for Smith. And Bancroft should not hide behind the "youthful naievity" flag. 5 year ban for him would have been just.
I think, Stewyww that this is an issue of semantics - it took the original comment 'for real' as in the sense of fixing results, not just cheating. Doping in sports like cycling is endemic, reflecting the limits of these as 'true sports' rather than pharma-chemical based activities that require a particular (enhanced) physiology rather than skill. Match fixing is the equivalent for cricket because you can't dope an ordinary bowler/batsman into a great one IMHO, but arranging results/plays is going to destroy the credibility of the game.
I have no problem with the idea of Smith and Warner losing their 'leadership' roles and picking up bans. Whether life bans are sustainable, I'm not a sports lawyer. However, even a year's ban (like Warne) would make a serious statement: providing it covered all forms of cricket, of course. Another point I made was that the opposition captain had been caught doing similar things, twice but picks up some demerit points.
The Saffer media doesn't seem to have reacted as violently as the Aussie media/politicians to their miscreant. The Aussie media storm I feel is a bit rich given what they're team has got away with in the past.
At least it's hidden the more important issue - England being hammered in a Test for only the 10th time. Ever.
-
It's got cricket on the front pages and as a major item on news programmes. More please!
-
Blatant and stupid, immature - sums up the likes of Warner nicely. I thought the Aussies seemed to have suddenly mastered the arts of reverse swing, which is normally our expertise...
-
Jason Gillespie on 5 Live suggested a couple of one day internationals as a justifiable punishment. What planet is he on. Some players would view that as a reward (ask Graeme Swann).
-
Well, we want to balance bat and ball and make test matches shorter, and bowlers complain that new ball to be effective last only ten overs, so reduce new ball availability to 50 overs .
-
Jason Gillespie on 5 Live suggested a couple of one day internationals as a justifiable punishment. What planet is he on. Some players would view that as a reward (ask Graeme Swann).
Planet ECB.
-
Whitewash currently ongoing
-
Jason Gillespie on 5 Live suggested a couple of one day internationals as a justifiable punishment. What planet is he on. Some players would view that as a reward (ask Graeme Swann).
Planet ECB.
Ah come on, I'd bet Dizzy pops up as coach in the next few weeks, so he's hardly going to ask for his skipper to be banned for life.
-
I'm not sure why people seem so convinced that Lehmann was involved in this. How many people does it take to put a plan together of rubbing a bit of sandpaper onto a ball?
It seems that Warner was the "brains" behind it.
Jim Maxwell thinks that even Smith wasn't that aware of what was happening.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p062j4g5
-
Because as soon as the offence was shown on the big screen at the ground Lehmann was on the walkie talkie to the 12th man who then hot footted it out to the middle to talk to Bancroft. Then Bancroft puts the sandpaper (ouch) down his trousers.
I rest my case y'honour.
-
Because as soon as the offence was shown on the big screen at the ground Lehmann was on the walkie talkie to the 12th man who then hot footted it out to the middle to talk to Bancroft. Then Bancroft puts the sandpaper (ouch) down his trousers.
I rest my case y'honour.
It's still more than possible that he only found out himself by watching it on the big screen. It was pretty obvious from that what was happening. I just can't believe that a group of 4 or 5 plus people would have all been stupid enough to agree to a plan like this. Warner on the other hand seems exactly like the kind of person who would do it.
-
Lehmann may not have actually been involved in the plot but he has overseen the culture where this has been allowed to happen. His team are a boorish lot who the rest of the cricket world seem to dislike intently. If they want to clean up their act he should be sacked. If he had a shred of decency he would resign.
The one year suspensions imposed on Warner and Smith are, I suspect, the least they thought they could impose before the lawyers started talking about restraint of trade etc. In reality Australia have very little cricket in the next few months apart from the meaningless one day tour to England so the actual ban is the first part of the next home season.
-
Well, look on the bright side. There are now two fine batsmen (Smith and Warner) who are available for the 2018 county season.
Bancroft is already contracted to Somerset.
Any takers? No? Thought not.
-
Lehmann may not have actually been involved in the plot but he has overseen the culture where this has been allowed to happen. His team are a boorish lot who the rest of the cricket world seem to dislike intently. If they want to clean up their act he should be sacked. If he had a shred of decency he would resign.
The one year suspensions imposed on Warner and Smith are, I suspect, the least they thought they could impose before the lawyers started talking about restraint of trade etc. In reality Australia have very little cricket in the next few months apart from the meaningless one day tour to England so the actual ban is the first part of the next home season.
The knock on effect of that though is that both have lost their lucrative IPL contracts as well.
-
Well, look on the bright side. There are now two fine batsmen (Smith and Warner) who are available for the 2018 county season.
Bancroft is already contracted to Somerset.
Any takers? No? Thought not.
I can't believe Somerset wont cancel his contract and Cricket Australia having banned him for 9 months would probably ban him from coming anyway.
-
Can't ban him from overseas jobs. Restraint of trade old chap.
-
Can't ban him from overseas jobs. Restraint of trade old chap.
But, as the IPL have pulled out, why shouldn't Somerset?
-
Can't ban him from overseas jobs. Restraint of trade old chap.
To play in overseas leagues you need a No Objection Certificate from your countries board. I presume it's the same for other competitions like the County Championship.
http://www.espn.co.uk/cricket/story/_/id/19451005/new-noc-framework-required-federation-international-cricketers-associations
As things currently stand, however, even if they are not playing for Australia, the players and the league they intend to play in require an NOC from CA to participate. FICA put forward a hypothetical situation whereby a board "might now attempt to rely on existing ICC regulations to restrict players who are not contracted from playing in domestic T20 leagues" and argue that it may constitute a restraint of trade, open to legal challenge.
Section 32A in the ICC's operating manual is the relevant one dealing with the matter. It makes clear that the NOC applies to all players, whether or not they are contracted by their member board (so it would apply to cricketers such as Warner, even if he was no longer centrally contracted by CA) and even if they are retired.
-
Excellent article "What's with the sanctimony, Mr Waugh?" by Osman Samiuddin http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/22961057 (http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/22961057).
I feel the Aussies tend to put themselves on a moral pedestal, not reflected in their actual approach to the game. Similarly, the crass overreaction by Cricket Australia and Aussie media/tinpot politicians is just as bad: talk about getting retribution for the players strike threats. Obviously the position of captain/vc/coach was difficult, but is it that much worse to scratch a ball as to lick a ball?
-
To fully understand the reasons for the reaction in Oz you need to appreciate how important a part cricket plays in the national life of the country. It's massive. The national newspapers typically have several pages devoted to reporting/analysing the national team.
Participation levels are something we in the UK can only dream about.
-
To fully understand the reasons for the reaction in Oz you need to appreciate how important a part cricket plays in the national life of the country. It's massive. The national newspapers typically have several pages devoted to reporting/analysing the national team.
Participation levels are something we in the UK can only dream about.
Well, actually it hasn't been for sometime - unbelievably Aussie Rules (glorified bar fight in clinging singlets) and rugby (insert the obligatory 'odd shaped balls' quip here) as well as Footie had overtaken it. That's why the Big Bash League has been important for the game - as much as we all dislike 20/20 cricket.
I do know that Aussies tend to make up myths about themselves - the whole concept of 'mateship' for example - but just look at the cheating on the field, the pathetic politicians (although they seem to not be Australian) etc. This whole episode has been seemingly an excuse to wallow in this mythmaking.
Oh and whilst we're at it - this is cheating to win, not like spot/match fixing which is cheating to lose. The former is cheating the opposition, the latter is cheating the paying punter - which is ultimately what'll kill a professional sport. I'm not condoning the actions of the Smith/Bacroft/Warner 'leadership group' (plus the others who had a pretty good idea what was going on) but what happened to us in 2009 was far worse.
-
They have been caught out. Take responsibility for your actions, accept the punishment and hopefully they will all come back as better people and cricketers.
-
Ball tampering is to gain an advantage whereas match fixing is deciding the outcome regardless. No comparison between the two in my view.
-
Now Warner cries for the cameras. Seeing a bully upset does nothing to excuse all his antics over the years. They are going on about looking after his mental health now but nothing was said about the welfare of his numerous victims. He has been found out and should pay the price.
-
I saw the press conference. Did anyone catch the small person under the table peeling onions.
-
Is it wrong for us to laugh every time we see a whingeing Aussie (would have used a colloquialism) on the TV?
Lynda and Steve
-
Is it wrong for us to laugh every time we see a whingeing Aussie (would have used a colloquialism) on the TV?
Lynda and Steve
No longer a whingeing Aussie but a crying one.