Some people seem to have an obsession with umpiring bias lately. Historically, umpires used to be nominated by each county and naturally they tended to nominate their own old players who were hard up and in need of a job. Up to the late 1930s they did not stand in matches involving the county that had nominated them, but eventually it was realised that as a body they were at least trying to be scrupulously fair and were henceforward allowed to stand in any match unless they requested otherwise, which was rare (I believe Mark Benson never stood in Kent matches). The majority of current ex-player umpires played for more than one county so if the original restrictions were re-introduced some counties would meet the same small group of umpires again and again, unless a lot of non-ex-players were appointed. I just can't see that this is remotely justified however much we may all disagree with particular decisions-and, incidentally, as far as I recall Ian Gould was sacked rather acrimoniously as a coach by Middlesex so any bias might be the other way!