Essex Outfielder : The Unofficial Essex CCC Forum

Off-Topic => In The Hut => Topic started by: Perov on October 03, 2019, 07:02:13 AM

Title: Sacked.
Post by: Perov on October 03, 2019, 07:02:13 AM
The ECB boss Ashley Giles (the King of Spain) has dismissed Andy Flower, Peter Such, and Kevin Shine from their posts.

Not sure how good they were at their jobs, but it was interesting hearing Cork talk about England coaching during the Somerset match.
He argued that if a player performs well enough to get selected for the Lions or England squads they must be doing something right.
Why then let the England coaches try and change techniques, fill their heads with stats,  remodel  actions, and make players "overthink" their game?
I do think Jamie Porter, whilst still doing OK, is not the bowler he was, since being inside the England set up.
Ramprakash mentioned how hard he was running in, and maybe trying too hard.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: Oldhasbeen on October 03, 2019, 09:51:32 AM
Didn't see that coming!

Giles always comes across as a rather conservative, don't-rock-the-boat sort of guy, maybe he's got more radical ideas than most of us expected.

Re Porter, I'd be very interested in Andre Nel's take on his bowling. His action has definitely lost some rhythm, it's possible Shine's coaching may be responsible for this, but there could be other reasons.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: nat on October 03, 2019, 10:32:05 AM
Re: Porter - never mind his bowling has Kevin Shine been coaching his batting?! Gone from bad to worse.

On his bowling he was due a fallow year and relatively speaking that is what has happened. Not such a bad thing and he would be well advised to have a long winter rest...and then come and see me!
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: JasonP on October 03, 2019, 11:13:36 AM
Paul Walter was the one that came to mind for me when it comes to Kevin Shine.

https://www.essexcricket.org.uk/2017/10/05/walter-named-in-ecb-winter-pace-programme/

His bowling has gone backwards since going on the ECB winter programme a couple of winters ago.  Most of the others from this course haven't exactly pulled up any trees either.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: Andy on October 03, 2019, 06:12:52 PM
Yes, there's certainly a pattern with the seam bowling. 

I will say that NoPaint gave a good example of how to 'coach' at the highest levels: when Gough came to us from Yorkshire, he felt that he wasn't getting his body into the right position and thought it might be something to do with his left arm (?), so NoPaint watched him and noted that this was the case and made suggestions as to how to rectify this. 

The key point is that this did not involve a massive change in action and that the player was very much on board with the coaches' suggestions.  Too much coaching can be 'done to' a player, rather than 'done with'.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: nat on October 03, 2019, 07:00:32 PM
Exactly my coaching philosophy...do as little as possible...for as much money as possible.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: Mootown on October 31, 2019, 08:56:07 AM
Shine ruined many a career at the higher level. Awful ideas as a a coach.
Title: Re: Sacked.
Post by: Valentines Park on November 14, 2019, 11:46:35 AM
Shine ruined many a career at the higher level. Awful ideas as a a coach.

Glad he's gone to Notts then.  ;D