Essex Outfielder : The Unofficial Essex CCC Forum
Off-Topic => In The Hut => Topic started by: essexfan548 on September 29, 2018, 11:26:07 AM
-
I thought posters might like to read this: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/2018/09/27/english-cricket-end-of-season-review-sam-curran-rory-burns-have/
Some extracts:
Best Championship match
Why look further than Surrey losing to Essex by one wicket in a glorious exhibition of four-day cricket on an excellent pitch?
ECB's three biggest PR disasters
* The Hundred. Alienated everyone from the moment it was mentioned.
* England’s 1000th Test v India at Edgbaston. Could anything have been cheaper and shoddier than launching it with the presentation of two salvers?
* Surrey win the County Championship in style at Worcester but no sign of a trophy. [not sure I agree as points could have been deducted and we had to wait last season]
Most casual preparation
India warming up for the Test series with nothing more than a three-day 18-a-side game against Essex. You reap what you sow: 4-1 to England.
-
In addition - three questions we have often asked on here
Three biggest county mysteries
* Why are Nottinghamshire unable to produce batsmen of their own, without pillaging neighbouring counties?
* Why are Surrey unable to produce pace bowlers of their own, who do not hail from southern Africa?
* Why are Hampshire unable to produce pace bowlers of their own, who are not Kolpaks?
Love it!
-
yep a good summing up.
-
I thought posters might like to read this: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/2018/09/27/english-cricket-end-of-season-review-sam-curran-rory-burns-have/
Some extracts:
Best Championship match
Why look further than Surrey losing to Essex by one wicket in a glorious exhibition of four-day cricket on an excellent pitch?
ECB's three biggest PR disasters
* The Hundred. Alienated everyone from the moment it was mentioned.
* England’s 1000th Test v India at Edgbaston. Could anything have been cheaper and shoddier than launching it with the presentation of two salvers?
* Surrey win the County Championship in style at Worcester but no sign of a trophy. [not sure I agree as points could have been deducted and we had to wait last season]
Most casual preparation
India warming up for the Test series with nothing more than a three-day 18-a-side game against Essex. You reap what you sow: 4-1 to England.
Surely they'd have prefered to get it at The Oval anyway. It was much better for Essex to get the trophy at Chelmsford in front of a good crowd of our supporters rather than at Edgbaston or the Rose Bowl at the end of last year
-
Yes - it was great getting the trophy at Chelmsford and beating Yorkshire so comprehensively did put the cherry on top. That's why I disagreed.
-
They missed out the most unsporting moment of the season.
The tattoo man can "shoulder" the blame for that.
-
Surrey win the County Championship in style at Worcester but no sign of a trophy. [not sure I agree as points could have been deducted and we had to wait last season]
That's precisely the point of course. Now that there are potentially penalties for slow over rates, the presentation has to be at the end of the last match just in case the top team gets penalised (ok I know that was almost impossible for us last year and Surrey this, with the enormous leads we both had, but them's the rules!) Contrast when we won in 1992, the only penalties possible were for poor pitches, and when we clinched the title at home v Hampshire, the presentation was after that match even though we still had two matches left, but they were away so we couldn't be penalised. However, I think I'm right in saying that in 1991, although we didn't clinch the title until our last match (at home to Middlesex and the famous 51 all out), there was no presentation at all after the match and it was not until the autumn that the players were invited to Buck House to receive the trophy from Prince Philip. Perhaps Mr Graves might reintroduce a presentation behind closed doors to make sure he doesn't get barracked......
-
The Essex batting averages tell a sorry tale.
If you ignore Vijay our top performers where Bopara (41.7) and Tendo (37.5). Then comes Cook (the elder) and Wheater (34).
Looking at the openers, Browne (24.4) and Chopra (15.5) didn't distinguish themselves. Only three players passed 500 runs, thankfully we have Chef back full time next year.
Room for improvement next year
-
The Essex batting averages tell a sorry tale.
If you ignore Vijay our top performers where Bopara (41.7) and Tendo (37.5). Then comes Cook (the elder) and Wheater (34).
Looking at the openers, Browne (24.4) and Chopra (15.5) didn't distinguish themselves. Only three players passed 500 runs, thankfully we have Chef back full time next year.
Room for improvement next year
Excluding Surrey batsmen *all* Div 1 county batsmen averages are a sorry tale. The point being ... all cricket stats are relative. However you are right that the Essex batsmen need to improve if we are to win Div 1 again.
-
The Essex batting averages tell a sorry tale.
If you ignore Vijay our top performers where Bopara (41.7) and Tendo (37.5). Then comes Cook (the elder) and Wheater (34).
Looking at the openers, Browne (24.4) and Chopra (15.5) didn't distinguish themselves. Only three players passed 500 runs, thankfully we have Chef back full time next year.
Room for improvement next year
Westley's average of 31 was better than most, but still not good enough, and Lawrence, with an average of 24, was fortunate to stay in the team in the last month.
In (slight) defence of both, however, they were often in very early after the openers failed, and I can't help wondering how much better they may have done with an in-form opening partnership. Given Nick Browne's disappointing season (not just the average, he didn't look the same player as last year), I'd be very happy to sign another opener (preferably right-handed) to ensure competition at the top of the order, as Chopra clearly isn't a 4-day opener.
Only one problem - there's no obvious available British or (sigh) Kolpak openers on the market as far as I know.....
-
Excluding Surrey batsmen *all* Div 1 county batsmen averages are a sorry tale. The point being ... all cricket stats are relative. However you are right that the Essex batsmen need to improve if we are to win Div 1 again.
All? Whilst I appreciate that there are a number of high averages from players who've not reached the 10 innings mark there are those like Gary Ballance who've put together decent averages in the mid to high 30s. It is noticeable that Slurrey and Somerset bats dominate - but even they have to bat away from home. If Browne, Chopra and Lawrence had batted to a mid-30s par we would certainly have moved up a place.
-
Mid to high 30s averages are decent?! Oh no. No, no, no, no.
-
Mid to high 30s averages are decent?! Oh no. No, no, no, no.
What? When they are batting against d1 quality attacks in the middle of Autumn storms or on damp Spring wickets? Ideally we'd have two averaging mid forties at least with the others mid-high 30s, but if the latter isn't decent enough, then why are we paying Chopra or Lawrence?
-
When asked the difference between D1 & D2 I always feel that the bowlers are better, in Div 1 each side normally has 1/2 top bowlers with the rest decent, Div 2 a side normally has 1 top bowler, 2 reasonable plus a couple of average bowlers, so naturally when a side is promoted the batsmen will struggle, batsmen have to really graft for their runs, you don't normally get so many loose balls & crease occupation is essential, you have to work harder for your runs, in other words batting averages are likely to be lower as witnessed this season generally in Div 1.
-
These are the batting averages of the team that finished 2nd in Division 2, winning 10 out of 14 matches. Not 1 over 35. 16 batting points. Shows how difficult it's been this season.
http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/records/averages/batting_bowling_by_team.html?id=12180;team=1149;type=tournament
-
These are the batting averages of the team that finished 2nd in Division 2, winning 10 out of 14 matches. Not 1 over 35. 16 batting points. Shows how difficult it's been this season.
http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/records/averages/batting_bowling_by_team.html?id=12180;team=1149;type=tournament
Well, maybe the quality of batsmanship is also lower than in D1?
-
These are the batting averages of the team that finished 2nd in Division 2, winning 10 out of 14 matches. Not 1 over 35. 16 batting points. Shows how difficult it's been this season.
http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/records/averages/batting_bowling_by_team.html?id=12180;team=1149;type=tournament
Well, maybe the quality of batsmanship is also lower than in D1?
I'm sure the bowling in D2 is of lower quality ... but I've also read several reports stating how tough it's been batting on Canterbury wickets this year.
I thought Heino Kuhn would be a great signing - good bat, not quite Test standard but a career average of 42, and at 34 probably a couple of years left in the tank, but he's only managed to average 34. And Sam Billings, who I'd rather hoped would join us when he was rumoured to be looking for a change of county last year, widely reputed to be one of the best players of spin in Britain, only averaging 31 ...
So I'd agree that batsmen averaging 35-39 in CC 2018 are doing pretty well. If our top 4 had all managed this .....
-
Kuhn did very well for Kent and scored a record number of one day centuries to get them to the Royal London Final.
-
If Kent retain their current squad, they might think they will do well in D1 but batting wise they will struggle, as with Essex the question is if you are going to sign reliable, consistent batsmen then who are they & where do you find them?
-
Kent need to keep Henry - I'm told they look a different side when he is not playing.
-
Kent will benefit from only one team being relegated next season. That gives them a reasonable chance of staying up as there are still several weak teams in division one and I am not convinced Warwickshire will do particularly well.
-
Kent will benefit from only one team being relegated next season. That gives them a reasonable chance of staying up as there are still several weak teams in division one and I am not convinced Warwickshire will do particularly well.
I hope the proposed new format of div 1 and 2 is not a done deal. We need to get our chairman/ceo to oppose it.
-
Why do you say that Nat? purely out of interest in your opinion mate.
-
Why do you say that Nat? purely out of interest in your opinion mate.
The proposal is another step on the road to reducing professional cricket to 10 counties/teams. We need to maintain (and ideally expand) pro cricket in the UK.
-
If division one is 10 teams then, for the championship to be 'fair', they need to play each other team home and away ... 18 games; that just isn't going to happen.
-
Nottinghamshire and Warwickshire wouldn't be able to survive without Div 2 cricket as they both use it as their academy.
-
Mid to high 30s averages are decent?! Oh no. No, no, no, no.
What? When they are batting against d1 quality attacks in the middle of Autumn storms or on damp Spring wickets? Ideally we'd have two averaging mid forties at least with the others mid-high 30s, but if the latter isn't decent enough, then why are we paying Chopra or Lawrence?
Quite right. Playing 4 day cricket on April and September pitches is probably the worst preparation for Test cricket one can imagine.
-
Mid to high 30s averages are decent?! Oh no. No, no, no, no.
What? When they are batting against d1 quality attacks in the middle of Autumn storms or on damp Spring wickets? Ideally we'd have two averaging mid forties at least with the others mid-high 30s, but if the latter isn't decent enough, then why are we paying Chopra or Lawrence?
Quite right. Playing 4 day cricket on April and September pitches is probably the worst preparation for Test cricket one can imagine.
Not when we increasingly play Test matches in Sept.
-
Nottinghamshire and Warwickshire wouldn't be able to survive without Div 2 cricket as they both use it as their academy.
Indeed!